Sunday 5 August 2012

Growing Up in the Times of a Civil War: The Ethnic Question in Elmo Jayawardena's Sam's Story



Sri Lanka was a land of war, bloodshed and violence until recently. Millions of innocent lives were taken away. There was no one to be called the ‘good’ or ‘bad’ here. Both the sides were bad. All they did was destroy the peace in the country and turn it into a feared place. Even till date many tourists who go to Sri Lanka face lots of problem. No one was spared. She won her independence in the year 1949. After independence, most of the economic policies were controlled by the newly formed government. Sri Lanka had a large population of Tamils, who had migrated from India long ago. These Tamils played an important role in the building of the nation and were very active in the freedom struggle. They had the sense of belonging towards Sri Lanka. It is obvious for someone to have such a feeling when they are born and brought up in that country. Things were good until the question of ethnicity sprang up. The natives of Sri Lanka, according to them, the Sinhalese were supposed to be given more priorities than the foreign Tamils. In 1956, the Government passed a law that made knowledge of Sinhala compulsory for any Government jobs. This was called the Sinhala Only Act. The very purpose of this sudden outburst was clear to everyone. It was the first ever step to exclude the Tamils from all the activities of the Government. Until then, many Tamils had influential posts in the Government. But after this, they lost their recognition. There was a massive protest against this step taken by the Government. To make the situation worse, there arose a war of religious identity. In Lanka, most of the Sinhalese followed Buddhism where as, the Tamils believed in Hinduism. The people made use of this as a weapon and continued their struggle. A war which was supposed to be Sinhalese versus Tamil turned out to be a war between the Buddhists and the Hindus. As the 1970s approached, the State economy began to crumble. It began to show its weakness and shortages. In the next election in 1977, UNP (a Sinhalese majority Party) easily managed to win. They introduced Sri Lanka to the global market. Lanka was one of the first of the third world countries to embark upon globalization. This gave space for many of the Tamils to invest in the market. The Sinhalese started having major issues with this rising of Tamils. In 1983, there was massive violence against all the Tamils. This in turn gave rise to many people who yielded arms, like Prabhakaran. Thus, a civil war was born. The war of the people against the State policies became the war between the two groups. This is a clear example of how a political war turned out to be a civil war during the times of an economic crisis.

We all know that literature is the reflection of the society and our own lives. All these happenings in the island country had a major impact on all contemporary writing. It did affect the lives of every single person in the country in some way or the other. So did it affect the writings. Elmo Jayawardena’s Sam’s Story is an amazing novel that describes the Lanka through the eyes of our protagonist and through his life and their events. Sam is portrayed as a slow-learning, poor, innocent boy. The story takes us through Sam’s life, explains minor things like why he dislikes the Tamil cook, his colleague and room-mate at the River House he worked, to major issues like as to why he hates the war. Sam is born into a large family of six members. He had two younger brothers, Jaya and Madiya, who join the army and end up dying for the war fought for no reason. His sisters Loku and Podi stay along with their destitute mother who works hard jus to cook the evening meal. They live a life of utter poverty.

            Sam was a very innocent and simple boy. He didn’t think very much about anything, thus he was not very worried about many things others usually were. He took life in a very easy manner though many things affected him. He believed that people were many a time just interested in asking questions to everyone about everything. They had nothing else to do, so they asked questions.
“I never could figure out why people asked me so many questions. Maybe they thought I knew all the answers to life. Even while standing at a bus stop, someone would ask me a stupid question.
‘What time will the next bus come?’
People always asked me things like that. How would I know when the next bus would come?
‘When did the last bus go?’
Now that is a really stupid question. I wouldn’t be here if I was at the bus stop when the last bus went would I?...”[1]

                Sam was always irritated with such questions. He never understood for what reason people asked so many questions. He also had a simple way of thinking. That is very clear from the answers he gives to the people who ask him questions. He was very innocent and never understood the fuss people created over many small things; small things according to him. For instance, once he forgets to switch off the lights at the River House[2]. And his Master gets very angry about this incident and calls him a fool. Sam hates it when someone calls him a fool, and he was even angrier because his Master called him that though he knows Sam was not one. He also mentioned that it was he who paid the electricity bill and was not to be wasted like this. At that instance, Sam thought to himself,
“…In any case he never the bills; it was Harrison[3] who paid all the bills in the River House.” [4]
                It is through this simple thinking of his that we get to know what the war has done to the nation and how much the people are affected, both physically and mentally. Towards the end of the story, there is a deep change in the thoughts of everyone, and that concludes what the war had done to anyone with a beating heart.


Sam hated the war right from the beginning. He had his reasons for it. This question of, ‘whose war is this?’ kept revolving in his mind. He totally disapproved of the fighting and never even understood for what reason the people were killing each other. But he was aware that it was the Tamils against whom the war was being fought. He knew that the Tamils were his enemies too, as they killed his people in the North. That was one major reason for him to hate Leandro, the cook. He had many other reasons like Leandro drying his ‘multi-coloured’ lankets[5], his closeness to Janet, the voting system to watch television and so on. But the very fact that he was a Tamil stood above everything else. He simply disliked the Tamils, whether good or bad. They were their enemies and that’s all he knew. He even hates his Master’s son’s friend who had come home from abroad. Even though she is nice to him and likes him, he dislikes and hates her just for the fact that she was a Tamil. Sam’s brothers, Jaya and Madiya had both joined the army to fight against the separatists in the North. For them, it was like a dream come true but only for a few days. Back at home, they had to struggle hard to even fill their stomachs. They didn’t even have proper place to sleep at home. They lived a life of utter poverty. But in the army, they were given clothes to wear, a place to stay and food to eat. Moreover, they also got some money which they could send home to their mother. For them, this was a comfortable life when they heard of it and joined. So was it for all the poor. Hence, it was only the poor who joined the war and ended up dying, for no war of theirs. It was a poor man’s war. The poor were being used as the pawns on both the sides by political leaders. It was a war for an unknown reason, at least for the soldiers who fought. The rich always sent their children away from all these by putting them abroad. The Master’s son and daughter were examples for this.
“…We are fighting and dying and the people in power who want us to fight are sending their children to other countries to keep them away from the war.” [6]
                Sam had lost both his younger brother in the war. He also got the chance to witness how cruel and false the army men were. He was working at Madam Martell’s[7] place when Jaya’s death had happened. When he got back home, he noticed that there were many people and a lot of arrangements done. There were drinks and biscuits for everyone; some men had given some money to his mother, the army had arranged everything for his brother’s funeral. They seemed very nice and the army seemed a great place to be in, with lots of care, affection and respect. Even Kada Mudalali[8] had spoken great of Jaya and mother when he had to speak.
                But it was only when Madiya came back that he realized the reality. Madiya had run away from the army understanding that the war was not fought for them but for the rich and the political leaders for their own gain. He was also afraid that he will be killed soon by his own men as they never left anyone who had run away from the war front. Madiya at that point of time was regretting his decision of joining the army. Madiya was so fed up that he says,
“’The war is over for me,’ he said. ‘I will never go back. They will have to kill me before they can take me back to fight for them’”[9]
                Madiya seemed to be very frustrated with the war and the people who were behind it. When Sam mentions about how nice they were when they came to cremate Jaya, Madiya jumped at him with anger. He spoke to them a lot about the war. Sam understood much, though not everything. But it was clear from Madiya’s words that this war was not a good thing. All it did was take the lives of many poor. Madiya gave a first hand experience of the war. He explained to them how the newspapers had been covering up many facts just to put up a good image for the ruling party. Since he had run away, he was sure that the army would soon hunt him down. He was very frustrated and fed up of all these. He spoke about many others who were in the same situation as him and had run away during the ten days off that they got after four months of hell. They were all hunted down by the army. They fought for nothing and finally went they got fed up and ran away, they were hunted down.
                He was also frustrated about the fact that it was only the poor who was fighting the war and for no issues of theirs. They were the ones who always spoke about the war and cherished upon it, but they never fought. They were never worried about the war and its consequences. He comments on the rich in frustration,
“’Where are they? They are not in the camps or on the lonely roads where the killing is going on. They are playing cricket or watching cricket or going to big hotels to eat their meals. They never go to fight. So they don’t have to die, or run like I did. They don’t have to be called cowards. That is the war for you.’”[10]
                He also talks about the worst living conditions they face while in the war zone. He spoke about how they had to work all time and had no sleep. Along with all the work, they were fighting too. He speaks about the other side too. This gives us some knowledge about the fighting Tamils also. He also feels bad for them as most of the warriors on the other side are children, even younger than him. To make it even worse, there were girls too. And the most affecting part of the war was that none of them knew what they were fighting for. They killed the other jus to save themselves, with nothing against them in mind. Madiya gives a very interesting and realistic statement about the war here,
“…I don’t think they know anything more about this war than we do. We kill them because they come to kill us, neither of us knowing why we are doing this to each other.”[11]
                This reminds me of one of Thomas Hardy’s poems, ‘The Man He Killed’, in which the narrator describes the scene of a war and a man whom he killed. He killed a man whom he never knew. He says that he would have shared a drink with that man in the bar where he was sitting if only he was not his foe. He killed the unknown man for the only reason he wore a different uniform than his. He never knew who that person was even. If he had not pulled the trigger then, the man would have. That’s all about a war.

“Had he and I but met
By some old ancient inn,
We should have set us down to wet
Right many a nipper kin! ...
…I shot him dead because-
Because he was my foe,
Just so: my foe of course he was;
That’s clear enough; although.”[12]

                                Sam had therefore lost both his brothers. This was one major reason he hated the war. It was also because of this that he hated all the Tamils. They were the ones who had killed his brothers. It was because of them that his small family had lots of sorrows and tears. Whoever the person was, be it Leandro, Janet, Velu[13] or the boy’s special friend who had come from abroad for her vacations. They were all the same. They were all bad and he could never accept them as his friend or even get close to them to that fact.
                The author also gives us an opportunity to understand the views of the rich and the upper-middle class. Sam works in an upper-middle class household. Whenever his Master has guests, he is the one who serves them with drinks. When he did so, he was required to be present there all the time. So, he happens to hear the conversations of these people. They often discussed about the war. But the fact was that none of them were directly involved in the war. All they did was discussed and complain about everything. Sam never understood why people complained so much. He assumed that if people do not have a solution to any problem, they prefer to complain about it. And all these, if there was no cricket matches in play. If cricket was on, that would be the only major thing to discuss on.
                In the beginning of the year 2000, it was only war everywhere. Everyone seemed to have there own contributions to the words about the war. From Lucky’s barbershop to Menda’s bakery, war was the only burning issue. They spoke about bombs going off at some place, some unheard road being captured by either the army or the liberals. It was the same at the river house also. Whenever visitors came, all they spoke was about the war.
“None of them had been in the war. Or, for that matter, none of them had anyone from their families who were involved in the fighting. The real conflict was far from them. But they talked; they always spoke as if they had all the answers.” [14]
                All the guests at home had their own solution to the crises. Some said that the Government must draw a border and give some land to the Tamils as they too have been living here for many years. Some said that all these must be settled by the political organizations by forgetting all their personal differences. Some preferred to sit and complain about the increase in taxes. They found some kind of relief in complaining about the leaders. Many were already thinking of leaving the country. They were also fed up of this war, but for many other reasons. Raji sir, Master’s friend and neighbour gave a very sensible statement,
“…’Only then will you see the real fun. When the deaths reach the rich and the powerful.’ He laughed strangely and went on. ‘Only then will there be serious considerations about how to end the war. Till that happens, this sick business will go on. For us, there is no battle. We all wash our hands off it. It is the poor who are affected…’” [15]
                They went on and on. There was also an economic crisis during the war. The people also complained about that and poverty. Sam at such times thought these people here don’t even know what poverty is and they are all commenting on them becoming poor. Sam had experienced poverty. This reality of war and poverty had made the people think the worse. Once Velu had taken off and gone to his village for some ceremony. He never returned after that. That incident gave a discussion point at Master’s place. Some even said he would have been a spy planted there to follow some motions. That was absolutely crazy! If only the war was not there people would have only thought he got some other better job or he would have had some emergency. But the war had totally made the people go mad. On the other side, poverty even made people lose their belief in their Gods. Once there was a discussion between Leandro and Sam about their Gods.  Leandro’s God’s picture was very ferocious. They had many arms and had weapons too.[16]Whereas, Sam’s God was very peaceful with his eyes closed and meditating.[17]He thought this night by the reason they always lost and he was afraid of the Tamils for this reason too. He considered their God more powerful and ferocious than his.
                Similarly, during Christmas, the River House was in full flow. There were lights, colours, sweets, guests and it was always cheerful. While setting up the Christmas tree, Sam had many questions. It was the first time ever he was celebrating some day called Christmas. He gradually came to know from the Master’s daughter that this was the most important festival for them. He also learnt about Santa Claus, who would be giving them gifts soon. On the day of Christmas, he received his gifts. He was very excited. He was very grateful to this Santa Claus for leaving few gifts for him too. After a while he asked the master’s daughter if he could change Gods. The girl was pretty shocked by this question. Sam then spoke out,
“…I said I was sure Loku and Podi wouldn’t mind changing Gods and making a tree for the Santa Claus man. Especially if they also got belts, dresses and bags like Janet did.”[18]
                He also thought that the Gods were always against the poor. He never understood the reason behind this. He had already created them poor; moreover he gave them problems after problems. Like the death of two sons, the flood which took away the leftovers of their lives, etc. the flood had not only taken away the leftovers, but also Sam’s one and only best friend, Piya.
                Coming back to the war, the war had created a very big impact in the minds of the people. In the story, towards the end, Sam’s Master dies in a bomb blast in a bank on his visit to the capital. After this incident, there is a drastic transformation in the River House changes. The old life and joy dies off. Madam leaves the place and goes to her children. Bhurus and Lena are given off to Mrs. Raji. The biggest transformation was in the attitudes of Leandro and Sam. They didn’t hate each other any more. They were really upset about what had happened. They never understood why their master had to die. He had never done any harm to anyone. At this situation, Sam tells to himself,
“There was no reason for him to die, but now he was dead.”[19]
                Even Leandro breaks down on this news. All this days he was proud about what his people were doing. He often threatened Sam that he would join the army some day and kill him. He hated Sam very much and Sam hated him back too. But at this moment, Leandro just had one thing to say,
“They should not have killed him, Sam…”[20]
                After this everyone returned to their own homes. The house was empty. Once back home, Sam started thinking about many things. His days of happiness at the River House, his small fights with Leandro, etc. they were all over. He was even ready to go back and adjust with Leandro. He hated him no more.
“It is strange how I don’t hate him anymore. I wish we could both go back in time and be at the River House again, sharing our small room. Leandro could do his cooking and fart as much as he liked and he could hang his lankets wherever he wanted. We could live there, not hating each other; I mean, we could just get on with our stupid lives without having to worry about things that were beyond us. No more talk about who is dividing the country and who is winning and who is losing…I guess there is lot more to people than how they fart and where they hang their multicoloured wet lankets. Or, for that matter, to which side they belong.”[21]
                This novel is just one more mouth to talk about what war does to us. All what war does is destroy mankind. Take examples of any such wars, it is only the innocent who end up dying; people who wouldn’t have even known the reason for the fighting, people who wouldn’t even know that there is a war happening. Such wars and crises only destroy human civilizations. It has been like this since the times mankind has seen fighting and wars. In Louis MacNiece’s Prayer Before Birth, the child fears about the present world even before its born. It asks God to kill it in its mother’s womb than being born into such a world full of desolation and darkness. I would like to end my presentation with a few lines from a song which I think pertains to this context.
“And how many times must a canon ball fly,
Before they are forever banned?...
…And how many deaths will it take till we know,
That too many people have died?
The answer my friend is blowin’ in the wind.”[22]


[1] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.1
[2] The River House is where Sam goes to work after he stopped going work at the White Lady’s place.
[3] Harrison is the driver at the River House.
[4] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.60
[5] Inner-garment worn by men
[6] Said by Madiya after he runs away from the army, fed up of everything; Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.118
[7] Sam’s first employee, a White lady
[8] Kada Mudalali is the local shop owner who later wins the election and becomes their leader
[9] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.115
[10] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.117
[11] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.118
[12] Thomas Hardy; The Man He Killed
[13] Velu is the servant who works at Sam’s Master’s friend’s place. He often discusses about the war with Leandro and talk about the death toll of the Lankans.
[14] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.135; Sam’s comment on the rich who sit and talk about the war
[15] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.138
[16]The Hindu Gods usually have images like that. Eg. Narasimha, Kali, etc
[17] Gautama Buddha
[18] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.89
[19] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.168
[20] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.169
[21] Elmo Jayawardena; Sam’s Story; Pg.170
[22] Bob Dylan; Blowing In the Wind; 1963

No comments:

Post a Comment